|

|
THE EFFECT
OF ALTERING URINARY pH ON URINARY SYMPTOMS IN WOMEN
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|

|
Authors:
|

|
LV Swithinbank1,C Rogers2,
J Ellis Jones1, P Abrams1
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|

|
Institution:
|

|
Bristol Urological Institute1,
R & D Support Unit2, Southmead Hospital, Bristol, United Kingdom.
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Aims of
study:
Detrusor instability is a common complaint among women. Anecdotal reports suggest
that alkalinising urine may improve symptoms of frequency and urgency, and intravesical
administration of sodium bicarbonate has been shown to increase bladder capacity
in patients with detrusor instability1. There is some evidence that women with
detrusor instability may have a lower urinary pH than those with stable bladders2.
This study was designed to determine whether alkalinising urine would improve
symptoms in women with detrusor instability.
Methods:
A randomised double-blind controlled study of the effect of placebo versus sodium
bicarbonate was conducted among women with urodynamically proven detrusor instability.
The dose of sodium bicarbonate used in the study was determined from a pilot
study among volunteers, and was the dose that increased the mean daily pH by
1. The study lasted four weeks and consisted of a baseline week, a week of either
5.4 gms sodium bicarbonate or placebo, a washout week and a final week of either
5.4 gms sodium bicarbonate or placebo. All women took both placebo and sodium
bicarbonate, but they were randomised to the order in which they took these.
Urinary diaries including information concerning episodes of urgency and leakage
were kept during all weeks apart from the washout week. Women tested their urinary
pH with labsticks three times a day during the study. A 24 hour pad test was
completed at the end of each week as well as a short symptom questionnaire.
General linear models were fitted to the data after log transformation. Baseline
readings and correlations between observations on the same patient were allowed
for within the model and F-statistics were used to test for differences between
sodium bicarbonate and placebo.
Results:
35 women completed the study. The mean age of the women was 49 years (range
23 to 71 years). The mean daily pH was 6.1 for the baseline week, 6.1 for the
placebo week and 6.9 for the week when sodium bicarbonate was taken. Table 1
shows the mean number of daily episodes of urgency and wetting, frequency and
24 hour pad weights. The difference in 24 hour pad weights was the only statistically
significant result with increased leakage occurring in the week that sodium
bicarbonate was ingested. There was no difference in the quality of life impact
of urinary symptoms for either group with the mean impact of their urinary symptoms
on their daily life reported as "somewhat" for the period of the study. Type
your text within this frame. If 2nd page is needed use Abstract Form A-2. Category
No. (Please choose one) Abstract No. International Continence Society 30th Annual
Meeting Tampere Hall, Tampere, Finland o 28 - 31 August, 2000 Author(s): LV
Swithinbank1,C Rogers2, J Ellis Jones1, P Abrams1 Table 1: comparing the mean
number of daily episodes of urgency and wetting, frequency and pad weights.
The means reported are geometric rather than arithmetic means in view of the
log transformation of the data.
Conclusions:
It is a common belief that urinary pH may affect detrusor instability, and the
variation between the pH of infused fluids and urine has been proposed as the
reason for the presence of increased detrusor contractility during ambulatory
monitoring when compared with routine cystometry. However, our study has not
confirmed this belief, as increasing urinary pH had no effect on the symptoms
associated with detrusor instability, apart from the 24 hour pad weight. The
number of wetting episodes did not change with treatment and therefore the clinical
significance of this result is unclear. Urinary pH alone does not therefore
appear to be related to the symptoms of detrusor instability. We feel that this
is important clinical information as it negates the advice often given to patients
with urinary frequency.
References:
1 Br J Urol 1987 60: 516-518 2 Neurourol 1990 9: 331-332