|

|
EXTRAMURAL
AMBULATORY CYSTOMETRY AS A RESEARCH TOOL TO QUANTIFY BLADDER OVERACTIVITY
IN RANDOMIZED CLINICAL TRIALS
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|

|
Authors:
|

|
Ernst van Waalwijk
van Doorn, Bary Berghmans, Michael Lansbergen, Joe Lai, Fred Nieman,
Ph v. Kerrebroeck
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|

|
Institution:
|

|
University Hospital,
Maastricht, The Netherlands
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Introduction Bladder
overactivity is poorly defined by the ICS. Descriptive terms like 'a disorder
of the filling/storage phase', 'involuntary bladder contractions, while the
patient is attempting to inhibit', 'detrusor hyperreflexia' or 'detrusor instability'
are today's confusing clinical practice. In this study "Bladder overactivity
is a dysfunction of the bladder, in which a subject has no or decreased control
over sudden occurring contractions of the musculus detrusor, in such a way that
this leads to premature passing of urine".
Aims of study
In this study we investigated the applicability of Ambulatory CystoMetry (ACM)
to assess efficacy of therapeutic modalities in patients suffering from bladder
overactivity.
Methods
ACM is performed according to ICS standards [1] with event markers at the actual
start and end of it, at initiation and cessation of voiding (entering, leaving
toilet). Episodes of urgency, time and volume of fluid intake (at least 200
ml/h), voiding as well as time and leakage volume of pad and pad change are
registered in a diary. Duration of an average ACM is approximately 6 hours,
taking place between 9:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. Gaeltec equipment and microtip
catheters are applied. There are no special provocative tests defined. After
installation and instruction patients may go home. At the end of the 6-hour
period they return to the urodynamic labobatory to finish the investigation.
Results of the ACM are: total monitoring time, number of contractions during
the filling phases and (mean) duration and amplitude of these contractions.
The diary provides number of micturitions, the mean volume voided, the total
volume drunk. Data of results are then used to calculate the Detrusor Activity
Index (DAI, [2]); the theoretical range of the outcome of this quantitative
model is lying between zero (non-overactive) and 1 (severe overactive bladder).
Construct validity of the DAI has been investigated by the sensitivity /specificity
with respect to correctly classified detrusor overactivity, the ICCR
(test-retest reliability) and the ICCA (inter assessor agreement).
The padtest (urineloss per hour during the A0CM) was also evaluated by the ICCR.
Finally, we compared the DAI (loss/hour, mean volume) as efficacy outcome in
clinical trials of treatment modalities for overactive bladders with conventionally
applied outcome variables like incontinence episodes/week, frequency/24-hours,
mean volume/micturition and number of pads/24-hours. For this purpose we used
the data from a recent trial (n=1022) investigating the efficacy of tolterodine
[3] and from a recently finished own trial (n=28) investigating the efficacy
of functional electrostimulation (FES). The effect measured by the different
outcome variables was translated into a so-called 'standardized effect' (St.Eff.)
in order to enable a proper comparison. If the St.Eff. for two groups is lying
at 0.20 it can be defined as a 'small effect size', if it is at 0.50, it can
be defined as a 'medium size', and at 0.80 it can be defined as a 'large effect'
[4].
Results
The DAI-score has a sensitivity and specificity of 86%, if 0.41 would be considered
as the discriminating cutoff point between overactive and normal bladder activity
during the filling phase. In a group of 21 female patients with LUTS (mean age
51.6; sd 11.4) the test-retest of the DAI (appr. 2 months) showed an ICCR
= 0.85. The ICCA for 1 observer obtained in data from 2 blinded observers
analyzing 111 ACMs was 0.96. The volume of urineloss/hour of padtest obtained
in the previous patient group (n=21) showed an ICCR = 0,87. Table
1 shows the standardized effects of each outcome variable in both studies. It
is striking that loss/hour and incontinence episodes/week, respectively, frequency/6
and /24-hours show almost the same St.Eff. for two different treatment modalities
representing a minimal effect, while the DAI shows a large effect for FES.
Conclusions
This study can be seen as a contribution to the construct validity of ambulatory
urodynamics and the Detrusor Activity Index for research purposes. The results
also indicate that for overactive bladder assessment, the DAI is a relatively
strong instrument for efficacy measurements compared to conventionally applied
outcome variables.
References:
1. Neurourol Urodyn, vol. 19, 2000: p. 113-125 2. BJU, vol. 83, Suppl. 2, 1999:
p. 16-21 3. Clin-Drug-Invest, vol. 19, 2000: p. 83-91 4. Foundations of clinical
research,Appleton & Lange, Norwich, Connecticut 1993: p. 653